Elon Musk Loses Bid to Collect $56B CEO Pay Package

Source: YouTube

Elon Musk’s $56 billion CEO pay package, the largest in U.S. corporate history, faced a crushing defeat this week. A Delaware court reaffirmed its earlier decision to rescind the compensation plan, ruling that the package was improperly granted. The judgment highlights significant flaws in Tesla's board governance during 2018 when the pay plan was approved.

The plan originally granted Musk over 300 million Tesla shares as stock options, tied to achieving 12 financial and operational milestones. At the time, the package was justified as a way to ensure Musk’s commitment to Tesla, as he was considering shifting focus to other ventures. However, critics argued the goals were too easily achievable and that Musk’s substantial existing stake in Tesla already provided ample incentive.

In a bold move, Richard Tornetta, a Tesla shareholder with only nine shares, filed a lawsuit claiming the package was excessive and improperly granted. The court ultimately agreed, citing Musk’s outsized influence on Tesla’s board as a decisive factor.

Elon Musk’s Legal and Financial Setbacks

This week’s ruling marks the second major legal loss for Musk regarding his pay package. Delaware Chancellor Kathaleen McCormick ruled that Musk had exerted undue influence over Tesla’s board, undermining its independence. The board included his brother, Kimbal Musk, and close associates like James Murdoch, further raising questions about conflicts of interest.

Musk attempted to sway the court by holding a shareholder vote in June 2024, where 72% of voters approved a revised version of the package. However, McCormick dismissed this effort, asserting that creating new facts after a legal defeat does not justify revising judgments. Her decision left Musk without recourse, although Tesla plans to appeal.

Adding to the drama, lawyers who represented Tesla shareholders in the CEO pay package  lawsuit requested a staggering $5.6 billion in legal fees, arguing that their work justified the amount. While McCormick called the ask “bold,” she awarded $345 million in fees, payable in cash or Tesla shares.

A Brief Look Back at Tesla’s 2018 CEO Pay Package Fiasco

The saga began in 2018 when Tesla announced the pay package to much fanfare. Musk, already a billionaire, did not take a salary from Tesla but was offered this stock-based compensation tied to ambitious milestones. At the time, Tesla justified the move as a way to retain Musk, who was critical to the company’s growth.

However, critics raised red flags about the board’s approval process. Tornetta’s lawsuit argued that the board, heavily influenced by Musk, failed to negotiate the CEO pay package independently. This was compounded by claims that shareholders were not fully informed about how easily the performance goals could be met. The court’s January 2024 decision to void the Tesla CEO pay package deemed it excessive and unnecessary, given Musk’s existing financial stake in Tesla. Monday’s ruling to deny the Tesla CEO’s bid for reinstatement reaffirms that judgment.

Will Elon Musk Still Have Time for Tesla? 

While Musk remains one of the world’s wealthiest individuals, the loss of his $56 billion CEO pay package represents a symbolic defeat. The ruling underscores growing scrutiny over CEO compensation, particularly in cases where boards fail to exercise proper oversight.

For Tesla, the case could have broader implications. The legal battles have brought attention to governance issues that could deter institutional investors. On the other hand, Tesla's stock has soared 44% this year, driven by optimism surrounding Musk’s relationship with the incoming Trump administration. This suggests that the company’s growth potential may outweigh concerns about internal governance.

As Tesla appeals the ruling, questions linger about how this case might shape future decisions on executive compensation. The outcome highlights the need for stricter board oversight and transparency in shareholder communications, particularly in companies dominated by charismatic leaders like Musk.

Do you believe Tesla's $56 billion CEO pay package was justified? Tell us what you think!

 Loading ...